I Feel Nothing for James Gunn
By Dan Brown
James Gunn is out as head of the DC Studios brain trust and everyone seems to have a strong opinion about his ouster, and Gunn himself.
Me?
To borrow a term, I’m Supermeh.
I’m having a hard time getting hopping mad about the whole thing, or even hopping happy for that matter.
Perhaps I’m the only one who feels nothing for Gunn’s misfortune.
After he made his name with Marvel’s Guardians of the Galaxy trilogy, Gunn was tapped to revive DC’s movie fortunes. Some people lost their heads when Gunn was put in charge of the company’s movie arm. Others felt Gunn was a wise choice.
When he started his reign as a studio baron, Gunn laid out a decade-long plan for upcoming releases, sketching a rough schedule for the movies and TV shows yet to be made – that will now never get made under his leadership. In retrospect, it looks like a fanciful wish list.
On his watch, he directed a new Superman motion picture (he couldn’t even be bothered to come up with a catchy subtitle for it), which was . . . fine. It didn’t put DC fandom into a frenzy nor did it piss anybody off. It did well at the box office, yet not Spider-Man numbers.
He also greenlit’s this year’s Supergirl, which did cheese off fans. It made roughly $126 million globally, against an estimated budget of $290 million, including marketing costs.
In other words, DC Studios took a bath.
Last month, the horror entry Clayface at least won its opening weekend, but failed to generate any kind of positive word of mouth. Gunn was also involved with TV shows like Peacemaker and Creature Commandos. I get the impression not many folks saw that stuff.
The online reaction to Gunn’s firing was swift, and divided into two camps with strong opinions: Those DC fans who feel it is the right move, and those who think the sky is falling.
I’m for sure in the minority because I don’t feel strongly either way.
Gunn’s better than some superhero executives at coming up with creative ideas, and worse than others. He made his name with those Guardians of the Galaxy movies, which were not the best, nor the worst, comic adaptations.
He did model Krypto on his own pet dog, which is a bit much, yet not a huge abuse of his position. I never held it against him. I also never rushed out to see the properties he made when he was the studio’s boss.
I wonder if the producers of superhero movies are like comic artists and writers were back in the day – they also seemed to be polarizing personalities whose work prompted strong reactions. Heck, Stan Lee died in 2018 and the debate about how creative he really was still rages to this day.
Or maybe I’m just a bad nerd.
I never felt much for Zack Snyder, either!
If you have thoughts about Gunn’s departure, I’d love to read them in the comments. If you feel strongly it’s a good/bad thing, I’d love to know why.
Dan Brown has covered pop culture for more than 34 years as a journalist and also moderates L.A. Mood’s monthly Graphic-Novel Group book club.






Leave a comment